
Discussion about phthalates has increased lately due to a recent report in the Pediatrics Journal. This report in the Journal of Pediatrics involved a study of 163 babies (a very small sample) that used fragranced baby care products on a daily basis. None of the baby care products were even tested for phthalate content, only the urine of the babies. The arguments surrounding this report challenge the veracity of any conclusions published in the report due to the flawed science, inaccurate testing procedures, and small sample size. You can read this challenge at the Cosmetic Cop.
It boggles the mind at how many of the promulgated ‘reports, studies’, etc are so incredibly flawed. Even someone with interrupted recall of high school science experiments remembers how one needs a reliable sample, the set up of a control, and proper testing that excludes exterior influences on the study in question. Worse, I have actually read some entities using this Pediatric report as a basis to stop using fragrance oils altogether… to switch to only essential oils. I LOVE essential oils, and I LOVE fragrance oils. But to ME, essential oils are precious, limited resources. Essential oils are commodities precious as gold, even the inexpensive ones like Sweet Orange essential oil. Additionally, essential oils are just not appropriate for everyone.
Essential oils, scent material or not, are still powerful drugs. There are some patients that just absolutely can not be subjected to essential oils, and are safer with either unscented or fragrance material for scent. There may still not be enough research on the safety and long lasting effects of phthalates to satisfy those saying phthalates are unsafe, but there is enough evidence to show that adverse drug reactions from essential oils and prescriptions can cause harm, even death.
I go back to my original philosophy of balance & moderation. I do not want Sandalwood essential oil at the price of our limited resources of being compromised. I do not want any essential oils at the cost of great swaths of land being taken from the poor for a paltry sum, pittance of wages, or their resulting dependency on our SuperConsumer’s appetite for ever increasing demands of aromatherapy essential oils. I like the sense of feeling that a balance of natural essential oils and synthetic fragrances allow for a moderated stewardship of our resources.
It was this mix of both natural and synthetic that actually shattered the very essence and concept of fragrance in 1905 also… Francois Coty was trying to pimp one of his tiny vials of perfume to a ritzy department store. They turned him down because they were not all natural perfumes like were the ‘du rigour’ at the time. He purposely dropped one vial in the department store and the scent drew the masses (quite literally, and this is what we call “guerilla marketing“). The combination of natural and synthetic is what has allowed scent to become available to the masses.
The Pediatric Phthalate study frustrates me especially because they completely disregarded the environment of what the babies in their SMALL sample were subject to. There are phthalates in all the plastics in the hospitals we use. The IV tubes, the bags blood and Saline are stored in, the cups that the pills are administered in. Homes are surrounded with phthalates… from the plastic shopping bag, milk jug, laundry detergent jug, the plastic bottles that formula is poured into. This study concludes that phthalates in the babies urine is the result of using fragranced baby care products, yet these same baby care products were never actually tested for phthalates, nor are any of the phalates used in plastics also used in fragrance oils!
We will have formulators though that will want to formulate and advertise that they are not only “Paraben Free”, but also “Phthalate Free”… and it is with this end that Southern Soapers Fragrances has made the P-Free™, or Phthalate Free Fragrance Category visible to the buying public. You don’t have to ask, you don’t have to justify, they are there “front & center” visible for all the buyers to make their own choices based on their formulating needs, marketing needs, and their client base needs.